eve-wiki-system/wiki-plan-review-blockers.md

EVE Online Wiki Plan Review - Implementation Blockers

Review completed 2026-04-16. Legal issues excluded per request.

---

✅ RESOLVED BLOCKERS

1. State Schema Definition

• Status: RESOLVED
• Reference: State Schema Definition

2. Wiki.js API Authentication Flow

• Status: RESOLVED
• Reference: Wiki.js API Auth Strategy

3. ESI Client Specification

• Status: RESOLVED
• Reference: ESI Client Design

4. Content Hash Algorithm

• Status: RESOLVED
• Outcome: SHA-256 standardized.

5. Git Sync Layer Specification

• Status: RESOLVED
• Reference: Git Sync Protocol

6. Validation Agent Scoring Formula

• Status: RESOLVED
• Reference: Quality Control Protocol
• Outcome: Defined 4-category weighted scoring with "Must Pass" logic.

7. Page Hierarchy Specification

• Status: RESOLVED
• Reference: Wiki Page Hierarchy

8. Failure Handling Behavior

• Status: RESOLVED
• Reference: Quality Control Protocol
• Outcome: Established 3-Tier response matrix and feedback loop logic.

11. Rate Limiting Specifications

• Status: RESOLVED
• Reference: Quality Control Protocol
• Outcome: Defined specific req/sec limits for ESI, MediaWiki, and Wiki.js.

---

🚨 CRITICAL BLOCKERS (Cannot start implementation without these)

No critical blockers remain.

---

🟡 MEDIUM IMPACT ISSUES (Need resolution before Phase 2)

---

🟡 MEDIUM IMPACT ISSUES (Need resolution before Phase 2)

9. Cross-link Generation Logic Missing

• Location: Agent A (line 114)
• Issue: "Generate cross-links between related pages" has no logic defined
• Missing: Link extraction rules, entity matching strategy, and placement rules

10. Content Merge Strategy Undefined

• Location: Agent D (line 172)
• Issue: "Merge structured data with human-readable content" has no strategy
• Impact: Cannot resolve conflicts between ESI data and wiki content

11. No Rate Limiting Specifications

• Location: All external agents
• Issue: Only Agent A specifies rate limiting (1 request/second)
• Missing: Rate limits for:
  • ESI API
  • External wiki scraping
  • Wiki.js API writes
  • Git operations

12. Page Template Schema Incomplete

• Location: Content schema section
• Missing fields:
  • Ship pages: capacitor, targeting, drone stats marked optional but required for validation
  • No schema for skill pages, item pages, or faction pages

---

🟢 MINOR ISSUES / CLARIFICATIONS NEEDED

13. LangGraph Checkpoint Implementation

• Location: Line 361
• Issue: Mentions both MemorySaver and PostgresSaver but doesn't specify which to use
• Recommendation: Use PostgresSaver for production durability

14. Agent Scheduling Mechanism

• Location: All agent specifications
• Issue: No specification for how scheduled agents will be triggered
• Options: Cron jobs, LangGraph timers, external scheduler

15. Asset Storage Strategy

• Location: Agent G
• Issue: "Download images to local storage" doesn't specify storage backend
• Options: Wiki.js asset manager, S3, local filesystem

---

📋 RECOMMENDED NEXT STEPS

To unblock implementation immediately, resolve these 4 critical items first:

1. Define the shared State schema for LangGraph
2. Specify Wiki.js API authentication strategy
3. Define ESI client implementation requirements
4. Specify content hashing algorithm and storage

No showstopper architectural issues were identified. The design is sound and follows best practices for agent orchestration with LangGraph.