Initial wiki structure

wiki-plan-review-blockers.md

@@ -0,0 +1,117 @@
+# EVE Online Wiki Plan Review - Implementation Blockers
+
+Review completed 2026-04-16. Legal issues excluded per request.
+
+---
+
+## ✅ RESOLVED BLOCKERS
+
+### 1. State Schema Definition
+- **Status**: RESOLVED
+- **Reference**: [State Schema Definition](docs/schema/state-schema.md)
+
+### 2. Wiki.js API Authentication Flow
+- **Status**: RESOLVED
+- **Reference**: [Wiki.js API Auth Strategy](docs/infrastructure/wikijs-auth.md)
+
+### 3. ESI Client Specification
+- **Status**: RESOLVED
+- **Reference**: [ESI Client Design](docs/infrastructure/esi-client.md)
+
+### 4. Content Hash Algorithm
+- **Status**: RESOLVED
+- **Outcome**: SHA-256 standardized.
+
+### 5. Git Sync Layer Specification
+- **Status**: RESOLVED
+- **Reference**: [Git Sync Protocol](docs/infrastructure/git-sync.md)
+
+### 6. Validation Agent Scoring Formula
+- **Status**: RESOLVED
+- **Reference**: [Quality Control Protocol](docs/validation/quality-control.md)
+- **Outcome**: Defined 4-category weighted scoring with "Must Pass" logic.
+
+### 7. Page Hierarchy Specification
+- **Status**: RESOLVED
+- **Reference**: [Wiki Page Hierarchy](docs/schema/hierarchy.md)
+
+### 8. Failure Handling Behavior
+- **Status**: RESOLVED
+- **Reference**: [Quality Control Protocol](docs/validation/quality-control.md)
+- **Outcome**: Established 3-Tier response matrix and feedback loop logic.
+
+### 11. Rate Limiting Specifications
+- **Status**: RESOLVED
+- **Reference**: [Quality Control Protocol](docs/validation/quality-control.md)
+- **Outcome**: Defined specific req/sec limits for ESI, MediaWiki, and Wiki.js.
+
+---
+
+## 🚨 CRITICAL BLOCKERS (Cannot start implementation without these)
+
+*No critical blockers remain.*
+
+---
+
+## 🟡 MEDIUM IMPACT ISSUES (Need resolution before Phase 2)
+
+---
+
+## 🟡 MEDIUM IMPACT ISSUES (Need resolution before Phase 2)
+
+### 9. Cross-link Generation Logic Missing
+- **Location**: Agent A (line 114)
+- **Issue**: "Generate cross-links between related pages" has no logic defined
+- **Missing**: Link extraction rules, entity matching strategy, and placement rules
+
+### 10. Content Merge Strategy Undefined
+- **Location**: Agent D (line 172)
+- **Issue**: "Merge structured data with human-readable content" has no strategy
+- **Impact**: Cannot resolve conflicts between ESI data and wiki content
+
+### 11. No Rate Limiting Specifications
+- **Location**: All external agents
+- **Issue**: Only Agent A specifies rate limiting (1 request/second)
+- **Missing**: Rate limits for:
+  - ESI API
+  - External wiki scraping
+  - Wiki.js API writes
+  - Git operations
+
+### 12. Page Template Schema Incomplete
+- **Location**: Content schema section
+- **Missing fields**:
+  - Ship pages: capacitor, targeting, drone stats marked optional but required for validation
+  - No schema for skill pages, item pages, or faction pages
+
+---
+
+## 🟢 MINOR ISSUES / CLARIFICATIONS NEEDED
+
+### 13. LangGraph Checkpoint Implementation
+- **Location**: Line 361
+- **Issue**: Mentions both `MemorySaver` and `PostgresSaver` but doesn't specify which to use
+- **Recommendation**: Use `PostgresSaver` for production durability
+
+### 14. Agent Scheduling Mechanism
+- **Location**: All agent specifications
+- **Issue**: No specification for how scheduled agents will be triggered
+- **Options**: Cron jobs, LangGraph timers, external scheduler
+
+### 15. Asset Storage Strategy
+- **Location**: Agent G
+- **Issue**: "Download images to local storage" doesn't specify storage backend
+- **Options**: Wiki.js asset manager, S3, local filesystem
+
+---
+
+## 📋 RECOMMENDED NEXT STEPS
+
+To unblock implementation immediately, resolve these **4 critical items first**:
+
+1. Define the shared `State` schema for LangGraph
+2. Specify Wiki.js API authentication strategy
+3. Define ESI client implementation requirements
+4. Specify content hashing algorithm and storage
+
+No showstopper architectural issues were identified. The design is sound and follows best practices for agent orchestration with LangGraph.